THE novel by Robert Llewellyn —‘How green was my valley’ — reached millions through its 1941 film adaptation by John Ford. Telling the story of a family in a South Wales mining community, it criticises the unjust labour practises of the early twentieth century. Earlier in 1887 the historian Lord Acton wrote to the Professor of Ecclesiastical History at the University of Cambridge, saying that, ‘Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.’ While this maxim now tends to be applied generally, it was originally a comment on religious institutions in general, and the medieval Papacy in particular. The truth of this statement is a reflection on our fallen human nature.

In the Gospels we often see Our Lord come into conflict with the Scribes, Priests, and Pharisees. These religious leaders are depicted as being more concerned with power and prestige than with the worship of Almighty God. If Religion is important then there will be a status attached to its ministers. They, therefore, have a responsibility to use this status for good, and to bring people closer to God.

In today’s Gospel it is the Sabbath, a day of rest. Jesus and His disciples are travelling, and the Pharisees notice that some of them have plucked ears of corn to eat. The Pharisees ask Our Lord:

‘Look, why are they doing what is not lawful on the Sabbath?’

‘Edrych, pam y maent yn gwneud peth sy’n groes i’r Gyfraith ar y Saboth?’  (Mk 2:24)

Jews are forbidden from doing any work on Sabbath, and the harvesting of grain, no matter how little, counts as work. This appears to be a clear-cut case, but Jesus replies as follows:

‘Have you never read what David did, when he was in need and was hungry, he and those who were with him: how he entered the house of God, in the time of Abiathar the high priest, and ate the bread of the Presence, which it is not lawful for any but the priests to eat, and also gave it to those who were with him?’

‘Onid ydych chwi erioed wedi darllen beth a wnaeth Dafydd, pan oedd mewn angen, ac eisiau bwyd arno ef a’r rhai oedd gydag ef? Sut yr aeth i mewn i dŷ Dduw, yn amser Abiathar yr archoffeiriad, a bwyta’r torthau cysegredig nad yw’n gyfreithlon i neb eu bwyta ond yr offeiriaid; ac fe’u rhoddodd hefyd i’r rhai oedd gydag ef?’ (Mk 2:25-26)

This story is recounted in 1Samuel 21:1-7. By referring to it Our Lord is making the point that if David’s actions were acceptable, then why is such a fuss being made about the disciples plucking a few ears of corn. Jesus underlines this by pointing out that:

‘The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath’

‘Y Saboth a wnaethpwyd er mwyn dyn, ac nid dyn er mwyn y Saboth’ (Mk 2:27)

The legalism of the Pharisees has led them to forget what the Sabbath is really about: rest. The point of having a Sabbath is to ensure that people have a day of rest. Instead this day has become bound up with rules and observances which neither honour God, nor encourage humanity to rest. 

Jesus and His disciples arrive at a synagogue where there is a man with a withered hand. Clearly this is another opportunity for the legalism of the Pharisees to come to the fore.

‘And they watched Jesus, to see whether he would heal him on the Sabbath, so that they might accuse him.’

‘Ac yr oeddent â’u llygaid arno i weld a fyddai’n iacháu’r dyn ar y Saboth, er mwyn cael cyhuddiad i’w ddwyn yn ei erbyn.’ (Mk 3:2)

Rather than rejoicing that God has performed a miracle, and that a man with a disability has been healed, all the Pharisees can see is an opportunity to complain about rule-breaking, and to bring an accusation against Jesus. Our Lord calls the man to Him, and says to the Pharisees:

‘Is it lawful on the Sabbath to do good or to do harm, to save life or to kill?’

‘A yw’n gyfreithlon gwneud da ar y Saboth, ynteu gwneud drwg, achub bywyd, ynteu lladd?’ (Mk3:4)

They give no reply because they know that in order to save a life one may break every rule regarding the observance of the Sabbath. Jesus’ knowledge and interpretation of Jewish Scripture and Law is superior to theirs. Our Lord then asks the man to stretch out his hand, and he is miraculously healed. No law has been broken. Instead someone who was suffering, and who was probably shunned and made an outcast in society, has been cured and brought back into the fold of the community. God’s power to heal and restore humanity has been displayed. The Kingdom of God has been announced in deed.  

The response of the religious authorities is telling. Do they rejoice at this miracle? The answer is definitely no.

‘The Pharisees went out and immediately held counsel with the Herodians against him, how to destroy him.’

‘Ac fe aeth y Phariseaid allan ar eu hunion a chynllwyn â’r Herodianiaid yn ei erbyn, sut i’w ladd.’ (Mk 3:6)

The Pharisees have formed an alliance with a priestly party, keen on political independence. Both sides share a common aim — to get rid of Jesus. This is because He represents a threat to their power. Our Lord’s words and actions are understood by the Pharisees as an assault on their privileged position, with their innate goodness being ignored. From the start of His public ministry, Christ faces opposition from people who want Him dead. They think that they can destroy Jesus, and that will be the end of the matter, whereas it will only be the beginning. Our Lord will die on a Cross, but will be raised to new life at Easter. Calvary and the Empty Tomb are the salvation of humanity, part of God’s plan.

As Christians we gather on the Lord’s Day, the first day of the week, to celebrate Christ’s Death and Resurrection. By means of the Eucharist, we do that which Jesus commanded us to do until He comes again. For one hundred thousand successive Sundays the faithful have gathered to share in Holy Communion, because it matters, it is important. We are fed with the Bread of Angels, with the Body and Blood of Christ, so that we may be healed and given a foretaste of Heaven.

So, my brothers and sisters, let us rejoice in the healing salvation of Christ. Let us proclaim the Good News, so that all people may come to know, and love, God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit. To whom be ascribed all glory, dominion, and power, now and forever. Amen.

James Tissot – The Man with a withered hand (Brooklyn Museum)
Tissot: The Disciples Eat Wheat on the Sabbath (Brooklyn Museum)

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.